Reviewing schema
Compiler Seminar: Programming language design and implementation
We have 5 students in the course.
We will review
10 papers.
Every paper will be reviewed by 2 students.
Hence, every student will write 4 reviews.
Also, every student will give feedback to 4 reviews.
There are 2 rounds. In every round, 5 papers will be reviewed.
Two students who are assigned the same
paper are called peers of each other
for this paper. Hence, each student has 2 peers per round.
First round (week 37+38):
| |
Student 1
Peter Bunus |
Student 2
Peter Aronsson |
Student 3
Ilie Savga |
Student 4
Andrzej Bednarski |
Student 5
Adrian Pop |
| First week / first paper: |
Paper 1 Review |
Paper 2 Review |
Paper 3 Review |
Paper 4 Review |
Paper 5 Review |
| Second week / second paper: |
Paper 2 Review |
Paper 3 Review |
Paper 4 Review |
Paper 5 Review |
Paper 1 Review |
Example: Student 1 and 5 are peers for paper 1.
Student 1 and 2 are peers for paper 2.
Second round (weeks 39+40):
| |
Student 1
Peter Bunus |
Student 2
Peter Aronsson |
Student 3
Ilie Savga |
Student 4
Andrzej Bednarski |
Student 5
Adrian Pop |
| Third week / third paper: |
Paper 6 Review |
Paper 7 Review |
Paper 8 Review |
Paper 9 Review |
Paper 10 Review |
| Fourth week / fourth paper: |
Paper 8 Review |
Paper 9 Review |
Paper 10 Review |
Paper 6 Review |
Paper 7 Review |
Week 36
Introduction, distribution of papers
Week 37
Read your first and your second paper.
Write a review of your first paper,
and send it to your peer for your first paper
(cc course leader) by thursday 12:00.
Your first paper's peer gives you feedback
(cc course leader) by friday.
In the same way you give feedback to
your second paper's peer (cc course leader).
You revise your review and send the final review to the course leader
by tuesday of the following week.
Week 38
Write a review for your second paper
and send it to your peer for your second paper
(cc course leader) by thursday 12:00.
Your second paper's peer gives you feedback
(cc course leader) by friday.
In the same way you give feedback to
your first paper's peer (cc course leader).
You revise your review and send the final review to the course leader
by tuesday of the following week.
Week 39
Similar as week 37 with second round's papers. Note that there are new peers.
Week 40
Similar as week 38 with second round's papers.
Week 44
Monday 27/10:
We rank the 10 papers based on your reviews.
The best 5 papers are selected for presentation.
Each student is assigned one such paper for presentation
and one for opposition.
All reviews for all papers will be
made accessible to the participants.
Friday 31/10:
Presentations with opposition.
The schedule
will be announced later.
This page is maintained by Christoph Kessler (chrke @ ida.liu.se)