The debate about the Levesque-Pirri-Reiter paper that was started by McCarthy and Hayes continues now with an extended comment by Graham White. Also the authors have decided to change the title of the paper (conditional on the approval of the area editor, which has been granted in this exceptional case).

Furthermore in this issue, the Anonymous Referee 1 for Graham White's paper answers to White's rebuttal. At this point the author will get one more opportunity to answer, and then the accept/decline decision will be made.

Additional debate contributions have been received for the following article(s). Please click the title of the article to link to the interaction page, containing both new and old contributions to the discussion.

Hector Levesque, Fiora Pirri, and Ray Reiter
Foundations for the Situation Calculus
   Review protocol: [in this pane]; with links: [frame] [noframe]

Graham White
Simulation, Ramification, and Linear Logic
   Review protocol: [in this pane]; with links: [frame] [noframe]