Murray Shanahan's submitted article has now been accepted for the ETAI. The present Newsletter contains the referee reports; one of them also brings up a policy issue for which there is a comment by the present area editor. The policy question concerns the balance between placing commentary material in the question/answer review dialogue and placing it in the article itself. Should ETAI style electronic publishing make it possible to cut down on the breadth of commentary material in our articles?

We also have a comment by Murray Shanahan on another policy question, raised by an Anonymous Referee a few days ago, namely whether it is appropriate to debate referee reports. Finally a comment (called by him a 'grumble') by John McCarthy concerning the reference article by Levesque, Pirri, and Reiter.

Additional debate contributions have been received for the following article(s). Please click the title of the article to link to the interaction page, containing both new and old contributions to the discussion.

Murray Shanahan
A Logical Account of the Common Sense Informatic Situation for a Mobile Robot
   Review protocol: [in this pane]; with links: [frame] [noframe]

Michael Thielscher
Introduction to the Fluent Calculus
   Review protocol: [in this pane]; with links: [frame] [noframe]

Hector Levesque, Fiora Pirri, and Ray Reiter
Foundations for the Situation Calculus
   Review protocol: [in this pane]; with links: [frame] [noframe]