Feedback on the review of Paper 1 Paper: Lal Geroge, Matthias Blume. Taming the IXP Network Processor Reviewer: Peter Bunus Feedbacker: Adrian Pop In my opinion, the paper is reviewed correctly. However i want to point out that they have no real evaluation between the code generated by their compiler and some assembly code made by humans. Is great to have a high-level programming language for the IPX network processor, but if the complier generated code is not comparable (within certain limit, let's say 10% slower) with the manual (hand written) implementation of the same problem it will have no real practical use.